Friday, September 6, 2013

A Summer Potboiler: A Review of "The Darwin Elevator"


One of the pleasures of the summer has always been having the time and disposition to be able to read widely and deeply. There is something about the bright sunlight and the vista of expanded time that invites us to enter a recreational mode.  Some people bicycle, others hike, some people work on their cars in their garages, others just settle down with a beer and watch a baseball game. There was always the illusion that we have more time than we can dispose of, that we have a surplus, so to speak, and so we are less harried than we normally are. For those with a more practical bent, they might plan to undertake home improvement projects, for this is undoubtedly the time, and the sunlight is enervating. I’ve always been on the opposite scale, and have preferred to read, a taste that is shared by others, since we have institutionalized what has come to be known as the summer reading list.

There is more than we can possibly read, and during the year, I accumulate far too many books. I stare at them guiltily, and try to at least open up them and read a few pages before putting them down again, because during the other seasons, I have far too much to do. Summer is different. This is when many of us feel that we actually have the time and, indeed, almost obligation to make a dent in the pile of projects we have been accumulating, and our inventory of books certainly qualifies as a project. We can’t watch television all the time, can we?

Whether it be mystery or crime novels, spy novels, the latest Stephen King or Tom Clancy or Robert Ludlum thrillers, or more conventional fare that we would rather not confess to reading otherwise, there is plenty from which to choose. I would like to think that this would be a good time to read those earnest historical treatises we have always told ourselves we would read, the biographies of Lyndon Baines Johnson, or maybe a more polemical tract, such as Barbara Ehrenreich’s Nickel and Dimed, Christopher Hitchens’ god is not Great, or Jorge Castañeda’s Mañana Forever?, a provocative title that hits a nerve for Latin Americans and those of Latin American descent such as myself. But somehow, it isn’t the season for it, and we settle into more well-worn tracks, which usually involve escapist fare.

Rather than read the turgid prose of an Edward Gibbon narrating the end of the Roman Empire, who wouldn’t want to put themselves into the mindset of a hardboiled detective, or of a hallowed explorer such as Earnest Shackleton? Of all the ways to while away the time, I return to favorite characters and genres, and in this instance happen to prefer novels by Martin Cruz Smith, whose stolid investigator, Arkady Renko, has been a favorite ever since I read Gorky Park as a teenager. There are other characters that I can return to again and again, even if they aren’t part of a series, but the essence of them is that they are always perhaps a little perplexed, never truly happy, and can be considered outsiders in the true sense of the word.

Others prefer romance novels, those with the colorful book covers and even more evocative titles, suggesting a perpetual dreamlike stoking of erotic energies. There is twilight, there are dark and mysterious characters, there are exotic locales, there are vines and lush tropical verdure, and all of it seems to contour itself around the parameters of what we can term “literary masturbation”. Am I being dismissive of this genre? I don’t wish to be, because even if I don’t read romance novels, I recognize their equivalent in other genre fiction I have read, most notably, the “Gor” novels of John Norman, or recognize similarly how these elements (titillation, fantasies of rescue and/or seduction, and rivalries and contests in which sexual gratification in the form of a queen or princess or seductive other) is evident in genre writers dating back to H. Rider Haggard and others. There is an element of passivity in the object of sexual conquest, whether it take place in a colonial realm (colonial eroticism) or in an imagined future scenario that serves as the spice for action, without any need for a lurid Frank Frazetta cover (he of the impossibly muscled warriors and the similarly exaggerated female sex objects).

I have long come to understand that it is precisely the formulaic aspect of these works that affords such pleasure to the reader. They want familiar characters, memorable characters and familiar settings, a contest, a quest, a romantic triangle, a puzzle waiting to be solved. They appeal to the need for engagement that we all feel as readers, and as with all genre fiction, it is we readers who project our own fantasies and desires and mold them so that they are contained within the distinct form that is assumed by this literature.  We collaborate with the author by faithfully anticipating the plot twists and the complications that will arise, and by feeling satisfied that the correct sequences (the complication, the climax, the denoument) are followed, as well as the devices, for example, in the mystery or crime novel, take the form of the obligatory summation of the parameters of the case that has just been solved. The characters emerge as they always do, not much changed, and there is a certain cognitive comfort in this as well, for we recognize a pattern that has once again been upheld. When we speak of escapism, we do it on familiar grounds, ironically.

In my case, I have always enjoyed reading science fiction. This genre affords many familiar pleasures to me, ever since I was a boy and picked up my first volume of Ray Bradbury short stories, R is for Rocket, S is for Space. I could always lose myself in those stories, me being a kid from a working class immigrant background, and who didn’t quite fit in with the other kids on my block. It always felt like familiar territory to me, this feeling of instability that took place on familiar ground, this feeling that there was a puzzle that had to be cracked, as if it were the analogue to my own social situation. As I grew older, I always reflected on the points of similarity between comic books, science fiction, crime novels (especially Agatha Christie’s Hercule Poirot novels) and other genre fiction that I always read, and could even recognize points of similarity with works that explored the experiences of ethnic communities, from Jewish to African-American or Mexican-American authors.  The idea was that we had a set of circumstances and we were carrying out, so to speak, a thought experiment, with a familiar catalogue of crisis and conflict scenarios that we saw over and over again. It was perhaps also comforting to see that there was always a point of resolution, because literature relied on the grammar of storytelling, and there was always a resolution, even if in life this tended to escape us, or at least, me.

Science fiction is in reality a compendium of genres, and it can conform or at least incorporate aspects of travel literature, potboilers, crime fiction, Modernist analysis, psychological thriller, and other genres. When I was young I remember reading the somewhat caustic travel narratives of Paul Theroux, especially his The Old Patagonia Express, and feeling as if the old colonialist view of Latin America was still very much at play in his work. Fortunately, I was later able to read a more sympathetic and enchanting book that detailed a sojourn to Ecuador, Tom Miller’s The Panama Hat Trail, and found myself entranced by the incorporation of folk lore and the ability of the author to describe his encounters with people of all socioeconomic backgrounds, whether or not these encounters were accurate and not romantic cuadros de costumbres (quaint character sketches). There was also the lyrical account by a writer such as Bruce Chatwin of the psychic landscape of Australia, The Songlines, or Alex Shoumatoff’s evocation of Brasilia and the eternal frontier, The Capital of Hope. These books were powerful hallucinatives for a young man such as myself, and perhaps, they could also be classified as a form of escapist literature.

This being the summer, I was desperate to read a good science fiction novel, and after hearing a positive review on NPR, I decided to pick up Jason Hough’s debut work, The Darwin Elevator. This book presents another dystopian scenario, one set approximately two hundred years in the future, in which humanity has been struck by a plague, one that is somehow connected to the arrival of unseen aliens who have built a giant structure (an elevator) that reaches into the sky. We know little of the motives of these aliens, since there is no contact with them, but in their wake we have a plague that arises and devastates humanity, converting the majority into sub humans (or in the modern parlance so popular nowadays, “zombies”). Humanity teeters on the brink of extinction as a consequence. It is a shameless potboiler, a page-turner in the classic tradition of summer reading, with a first time author who nonetheless manages to capture a sense of wonder.

This seemed like a promising scenario, and it couldn’t help but bring back memories of so many other works I have read. While I tend to prefer quieter and more introspective science fiction novels, especially those of Ursula K. Le Guin, I was intrigued by the way in which this work promised to incorporate several elements (and formulas) that are so common in science fiction. One of these involves the idea of first contact, a trope that has figured prominently from the very beginning, havng been used to satirical effect in Voltaire’s Micromegas, and which was explored by H.G. Wells in his early The War of the Worlds as a critique of imperialism. Another involved the idea of dystopia, one that in this case may simply have been catalyzed by alien intervention, for the underlying circumstances of a humanity that was ever in crisis were ever present (overpopulation, intractable political conflict, opposing cultural spheres that seemed to echo the ideas of Samuel Huntington who had written in past decades of a coming “clash of civilizations” where cultural blocks emerged to subsume and replace nationalism, ecological devastation, etc.) The world is ever coming to an end, and we as a culture are obsessed with these scenarios of coming apocalypses, for don’t they tie in to the idea of human history as a story, with a much needed conclusion about to be revealed?

Also, I find myself asking, what is this obsession that popular culture seems to have with zombies? I don’t think it is entirely new, and in the past, we used to express it in terms of becoming as it were automatons, clogs in a vast and anonymous institutional apparatus. It was also transmuted into ideas of transformation and the blurring of differences, in ideologies that one can’t help but perceive as being based on racial differences, a fear that I can’t help but see expressed in the fear that many conservative sectors in this country have of a “One-World” scenario in which everyone has blended in, and in the cry of the Tea Partiers that they look around and they “can’t recognize this country anymore”. It is a fear, of course, directed against people like me, mestizos to begin with, who have yet oppose this ideology with visions that details a more optimistic and, quite frankly, realistic outlook. (Tracts such as José Vasconcelos’ La raza cósmica are early works in this vein, utopian but not grounded in real-life considerations the way, for example, Héctor Tobar’s much more recent Translation Nation is.) And is it not possible that there is another element at play as well, one that has to do with the way our economic system has morphed to assume a much more predatory and expansionistic guise, the Super-Capitalism of the 21st century that it is said is elevating many from a life of poverty, but which seems to have stumbled badly in the industrialized world, with the watchword being that consumption is necessary to fuel our economies. Is that all we are? Mindless consumers, stuck in a system that demands that we never have enough, that we consume more and more in a compulsive fantasy that is quite frankly ultimately unsustainable for the instabilities it implies? I can’t help but think that these are part of the underlying elements that underscore the fascination that zombies hold in our popular culture at this point.

In this novel we also have a mystery, for the have the encounter with an alien culture. It isn’t first contact, not yet, for the aliens don’t reveal themselves, but we have instead contact with their artifacts, those that are stunning to behold and evoke the feeling of wonder.  I couldn’t help but hark back to the classic science fiction novel of the 1970s that I read as a child, Ringworld, written by Larry Niven, and which details the exploration of a massive engineering artifact left behind by an advanced civilization. When it comes to these narratives, I can’t help but view them also as imperialist fantasies, for they allude to imperialism in all its facets, whether it be in the way one culture is reduced to the status of scavengers who try to glean what they can from the objects, or to the darker scenarios that involve conquest, the seeding, for example, of blankets with smallpox and other germs, to be distributed to Native American tribes in order to devastate them and make them easier to displace. In this scenario, after all, we have the arrival of a plague that devastates humanity, after all, even if it isn’t thoroughly established yet if this plague was brought by the aliens who constructed the mysterious elevator.

I am reminded of Jared Diamond’s book Guns, Steels and Germs, which attempts to offer an explanation for the destructive nature of these contacts, signaling mechanisms and ideological foundations that help to explain why one culture so dramatically changed and impacted another one. These are, one would imagine, mechanisms that are in play on a grander scale, and that is part of the fascination that I think we derive from these types of works, the idea that powerful civilizations decline and, as with our current obsession with zombies and our anxieties about the rise of China, that the world order (or in this case, American predominance) is being challenged, while another hidden order is yet to be established.

It was with these ideas in mind that I began to read The Darwin Elevator, hoping that these issues would be explored. But perhaps I was expecting too much from this novel. It is a classic summer read, in the fact that it is characterized by nonstop action, and by somewhat one-dimensional characters who react in clumsy ways that may be familiar, but that are nonetheless clumsy and lacking in the magic of writers of more considerable literary skill, such as Robert Charles Wilson or Olaf Stapledon. We have the pilot, Skylar Leukin, who gathers together a crew of like-minded adventurers who are immunes, that is, part of the minority of people who for some reason are immune to the plague and thus have more leeway for movement in the wreck of a world that has been left behind. We have also the eccentric but also visionary entrepreneur, Neil Platz, who has taken charge of the space stations that are constructed as a last refuge for humanity, and that gather together the remnants of the technological and scientific elite of this culture. And we have villains, which it pains me to say, are portrayed in heavy-handed fashion, almost in cartoon fashion, as is the case with the governor of the last human outpost of Darwin, Australia, a character named Russell Bleilock, who is singularly bloodthirsty.

The action is nonstop, and one is pressed to decide if the sub humans who have taken control of the rest of the planet and who, amazingly, are able to survive even as they are reduced to animal state, or if the manipulative directors and actors in this drama pose the greater threat. I am struck, over and over, by the mechanisms whereby these symbols of accentuated appetite (call them “subs” as they are called in this novel, or “zombies”) are able to survive in such numbers. To continue with the speculations above, are they just symbols for the projections of the fears of a bourgeois culture that sees in them the working classes of the present age, those that are supposedly destined to be the unproductive “takers”, to use the jargon of presidential candidate Mitt Romney? I wonder over and over about the layers of this obsession we seem to have with zombies, and even if they do revert to the background as dangerous “natives” that recall the nastier colonial narratives of our own past (they are anonymous, they are incoherent, they have immense appetites, they are singular physical specimens with little culture), they serve as a layer to the novel that all-too-briefly offers a limited measure of social commentary. They are an ideological construct that is used, over and over, to illustrate fears we share as a culture, at least bourgeois fears, for I can’t help but see in them familiar markers in the way ethnic and racial minorities are portrayed in this culture.

There is not enough exploration of these complexities in this novel. Instead, we have a thriller that relies on action sequences, in which the pilot Skyler always gains the upper hand, and we have a political situation that become more and more unstable as the novel progresses. The haves in the space station are in conflict with the have-nots on the ground, who are increasingly besieged by the sub humans who are pressing in and who threaten to overwhelm them. And, it turns out, the aura which the elevator had emitted, and which seemed to confer protection from contamination, is failing, and now there are outbreaks of the plague both within the city of Darwin as well as in the space station, a situation which was unimaginable.

While this novel was an undeniable page turner, I found myself ultimately unsatisfied with this novel. The dialogue was choppy, and the interaction between the characters was rendered in a way that seemed clumsy. Perhaps it was foolish to hope for anything like the lyricism of Ursula K. Le Guin or Gene Wolfe, and it is certainly the case that the author did not capture the psychological intensity of characters who seem too one-dimensional. It is hard, in other words, to distinguish at times between the subs (the zombies) and the normal humans, for what we have are characters who all seem to be driven by basic impulses, by fear, by jealousy, by anger, by ambition, and by the recourse to violence.

I look for more in the books that I read, but yet I was seduced at certain moments by this novel. I found this in the evocation of the gritty world of Darwin, the last human city, where an increasingly desperate human population, shielded by the aura of the elevator, struggles to survive. It is an underworld that reminds me in many ways of the movie Bladerunner. And, I found it in the twists and turns of the characters, who form alliances as well as betray each other, in ways that seem too melodramatic, but then, melodrama is a pleasure that I’m not prepared to renounce yet. And ultimately, I found it in the evocation of the aliens and their astounding technology. We may not actually see an alien yet in this novel, but there is something of a lurking presence that colors this novel. We may yet turn out to have merely another War of the World scenario where these aliens are yet another example of a culture bent on imperial expansion, but it may also be the case that the aliens are indeed benevolent, or at least, not as easy to characterize.

I hope that is it the latter. Aliens as angels or demons, yet another topic that I would like to explore in future posts concerning science fiction, for ultimately they must be seen as mirrors for our deepest anxieties as well as hopes. While Jason Hough doesn’t yet have the chops of the best science fiction writers, and this novel isn’t Solaris (the classic by Stanislaw Lem), he draws on the rich catalogue offered by this genre.
 
OGRomero © 2013
(Copyrighted by OGRomero, 2013)

Thursday, September 5, 2013

El interior (1st version)


Long, long ago, there was a small child who was thrown into a mountain, and who lived to tell of this.

She belonged to a community who lived on the side of a mountain. There were many such communities in the area, and it took a special skill and much accumulated knowledge to eke out a living in such a location, but it had been done for many years.

Her community was small but hardy, and their mountain was special. It was a living mountain, one that nurtured them like a father, but was also apt to punish them if they didn’t observe the necessary customs and rituals. The mountain, you see, was a hardy entity, and it frequently grumbled and coughed but, for the most part, it slept, like all the other old men of the community.

The soil on the side of the mountain was very fertile. It was suited for the crops that the child’s community had been cultivating from time immemorial, the various types of potatoes, the beans, and the vegetables that were grown in the area. It also harbored many trees, cousins in the minds of her community, for they also protected the people from the ravages of the weather. They provided fuel for their fires, as well as the material needed for the roofs of their houses, single room structures that were constructed out of rocks that were cut and carefully fitted together.

Most other mountains were rather cold and inhospitable, but their mountain was special. While others were silent, and cold, and were altogether less beautiful, their mountain boasted a rich black soil that was replenished at frequent intervals. Their mountain, known as Jurimayac, the old one, had an opening on the top, and from that opening there was usually a plume of steam that arose and drifted up into the sky. From time to time, but mountain rumbled, and the fire within was heard to roar, and scalding mud was thrown out, to coat the sides of the mountain. When it did this, it was best to scramble as quickly as possible to the safe zone, halfway down the mountain, and to wait for several days until the old one had finished replenishing the side of the hill. This soil was much prized, and would quickly cool, after which it could be gathered and put to use on their terraced plots.

The girl was born into a family of six, and was the youngest. She was plump, a quality that was considered beautiful among her community, and was furthermore very cheery and obedient. She was much fond of her oldest sister, who she considered almost like her second mom, as indeed she had been, for the oldest had been entrusted with the mission of raising her younger siblings.

Her appearance was unusual, and was the cause of admiration. She was small, but had pleasing features, and her forehead was broad and naturally slanted. Her smile touched everyone, as did her pleasing and modest laugh.

The family worked hard, and was much respected within the community. They had a plot of land, and they also had a herd of small native sheep that were much prized as much for their milk as for their wool. From time to time, a sheep was slaughtered during special occasions, but it wasn’t often, and instead, the sheep were considered a form of currency, to be traded with communities who lived in the valleys, and who would provide dried fruits and herbs that that traded with the highland communities. The sheep also served to cement the peace, for within historical memory there had been threats of invasion by uncouth and fierce tribes to the south who prized the sheep and the other products of the region, and as such, they had become part of a tribute that was paid to ensure the peace.

There would ordinarily have seemed to be little time for play, but the little girl was fortunate for her family indulged her. She had modest chores, such as helping her mother start the fire, or gathering wild nuts or herbs, or carrying water from the natural cisterns that her community had built to gather the rain when it fell, but often she was seen to be running along the paths that led to the upper reaches of the mountain, disturbing the nests of birds, and also, overturning rocks and collecting the small beetles that she found scrambling underneath. The beetles came in different hues, and they along with other insects were considered delicacies among her people, having a crunch and a texture that was quite pleasing. There were also subtle differences in flavor; the brown beetles were a little saltier, while the dark ones had a peculiar spice and aroma that reminded her of the mint that grew in damp places.

The little girl often called out to her oldest sister to join her in play. Long ago, this sister had taken her along a lonely path to a cave where her people had set aside to house the remains of their ancestors. When they passed away, they were bound in cloth, and they were soaked in a special oil that came from the valleys down below, and which was meant to discourage the rodents who might otherwise have been tempted to feed on the remains of their departed ones. The dead ones were stacked in different areas, where they could rest with loved ones, and as they dried out and grew withered, turning very dark, they were allotted a special period of twenty years in which their spirits could become accustomed to the idea of being dead, for it was deemed too cruel to administer the final rites too abruptly. After the passage of accustomed period of time, they were gathered together and removed from the cave and taken up to the top of the mountain, where the appropriate rituals were performed and they were entrusted into the care of the old one. They were dropped from the precipice, and special days that were determined by their wise ones, and their spirits were finally laid to rest.

During that journey with her elder sister, the young girl had felt not the slightest amount of fear when they opened the wooden gate and ventured in. It seems that the sister had been entrusted with the task of delivering a prized pendant to a cousin who had passed away a few years ago. The pendant had been considered lost until it turned up buried next to the side of the house, and it was deemed prudent to leave it with the departed cousin, who still had quite a while to wait until her final rites were performed, and must surely have been missing her pendant. The two sisters walked quietly into the cave, and they searched for the indicated area, and they had no difficulty recognizing the departed cousin, who was addressed with respect by the older sister, who placed the pendant under the cloth that covered her chest, and who stayed to tell her the news of the ones who were still alive, and of her mother and father, who were growing older now, but who remained in good cheer, and of her brother, who had welcomed a new member to his growing family, and was considered one of the more prosperous citizens of their community. She also told her of the fate of her promised one, who had mourned the death of the cousin, and who still loved to stand outside on summer afternoons watching the sky and the eagles who flew to their nests, but who had fortunately found happiness with another girl. Such a one would have made a wonderful husband for her had she not been taken by illness.

The little girl enjoyed hearing the voice of her older sister, and took comfort by the familiar and playful manner in which she expressed herself. Her older sister was a good storyteller, and always found the most entertaining way to describe the events that took place, the story of the brother who tried to ride a sheep and was thrown off repeatedly, or the friend who was as windy as the old one and could be heard far off on the paths that dotted the mountain, or the story of the old lady who professed to be blind, but who was apt nonetheless to unfailingly reach out to grab the private area of all the handsome young men, but never of the women, to the point that the men had taken to cupping their hands around their genitals when they approached her. She was old and her husband had lived for almost as long as she had, but it was joked that she had evidently not had her fill, and was thirsty still.

It was a memorable time for the young girl, and soon, in accordance with the customs of her people, when she had completed ten summers, she would be promised to her future husband, after which she would be entrusted to learn the ways of women, and to leave her playful nature behind. Her old sister had already been entrusted, and her ritual of marriage was soon to be celebrated when she completed one more summer, after which she would move in with her husband (who she already addressed as husband), and of whom she was very fond, having a romantic spirit as she did. The little girl wished to be betrothed as well, but to tell the truth, she also was very fond of the company of her mother and her other sibling, and could well afford to wait.

Now, it had been said that the old one, the mountain, was a living presence in the lives of this community, a presence that both nurtured as well as punished. It had been seen that to all old ones, especially to the oldest one, much respect was due, for this was the way of the world, and the source of their continuity. The old one could nurture, but at times, he could grow angry, and could shake and grumble, and could grow loud at times. In the past the old one had been seen to burst in anger, shouting so loud that he caused the top of the rim to blow away, causing landslides that terrified the people. It had also been seen at times that the old one would fall sick from anger, and would bleed molten drops that flowed down the mountain and set the trees and bushes they encountered ablaze. These tears could last for weeks and even months, for the old one was not easily appeased once offended, and while the people quaked in fear, they found it difficult to perform the ceremonies of appeasement.

The tears would flow down, and it was all they could do to gather their sheep and a few food stocks, as well as the members of the family, and scramble down to the valley. If the old one were particularly angry, it would also emit a sharp smell, one that was more powerful than they had ever noticed, and a gas that furthermore was poisonous to them, and might make them fall asleep. This anger was slow to awaken, and was slow to dissipate, so the community members trusted to the wisdom and experience of the wise ones, and were ever attentive to signs of anger. And they kept to the rituals, to the need to respect the sacred places of the old one, in particular, to respect the tunnels that were narrow and that located in middle latitudes, for these were surely the nostrils of the old one, and if the he could not breathe, would he surely not awaken in anger?

But there were other rituals as well. It had been the custom to choose a young girl to offer to the old one every five years, to have the old one have his fill as well, for the old one also had need of companionship. And thus, it was the custom for the wise ones of the community, the elders, to hold a special gathering every five years to choose the young girl who would be betrothed to the old one and given to him. The girl needed to be of the appropriate age, but much attention was paid signs that were the object of debate within the council.

Tariksa, the toothless one, insisted that the young one be upright and cheerful, and have no special fear of snakes. She herself had always despised them, and dreaded in particular the yellow ones with beaded patterns, who were like the sick excrescences of the mountain that was forced to eliminate its poisons, and when snakes abounded, she insisted, the mountain was bound to be afflicted with illness, and would surely grow hotter. Zumbatac, the elderly one of the large ears, insisted that the little girls who was able to attract beetles was one who had the same nature as the mountain, and rather than pine in loneliness or despair as a result of a marriage that she found unsatisfying, would be able to derive comfort from the material provisions of a mountain that surely abounded in beetles and insects. And Lortanac, the blind one, insisted that the true sign would be found in the sky, and that the eagles would surely indicate which was destined to be the chosen bride, for the eagles were acute in judgment, and prudent, and would surely recognize the same in the chosen candidate.

There were fifteen young girls who were to be betrothed that summer, and that summer coincided with the five year period that had been allotted for the selection of the new bride to be offered to the mountain. Now, it might be though that the parents of the young girls might have been alarmed over the possibility that their young girl might be chose, but this was such an honored and accepted custom among the people that they would never give thought to expressing their fears. Instead, it was said that the family of the chosen one would be especially honorable, for would they not have a close bond with the mountain, who would now become a formal member of their family? Was it not the case that they would assume honored status, and be accorded positions of leadership? Was it not wise to be dutiful and respectful, for didn’t their values depend on these qualities?

At the same time, however, it was also noticed that the families of the candidates became unusually officious during this period. They would be especially dutiful in their care of the old ones in the period leading up to the special gathering, and the wags would allege that some of the more devious families would resort to trickery. A few of the girls were coached to scream especially loudly when they chanced on a snake, one that would emerge under suspicious circumstances when many people were present to witness the reaction of the child. Indeed, girls who were born during these five year interval periods were known to be more afraid of snakes than usual, out of some mysterious mechanism that had to do with the knowledge of one of the selection criteria used by the conclave of elders.

In other instances, baskets of beetles were left near the sides of other household by mysterious visitors, and their presence was viewed as a sign of affinity between the candidate who resided in that household and the insects. Indeed, the young girl had always been told by her mother that she should not be so given to overturning rocks and seeking these beetles out, but nothing she had said would register in the young girl, who had always had a fondness for beetles, and while she was careful not to engage them in her mother’s presence, took no similar care when out by herself.

And, the families of the candidates were known to encourage their young daughters to spit at eagles, and to disrupt their nests, and to throw rocks at them, more so than the daughters of other families who were not candidates. The eagle was prized by the community, and it was observed that the girls who managed somehow not to be chosen reverted to the naturally respectful behavior of their other family members, but only when it was safe, and when the summer of their tenth year had passed. Otherwise, it was deemed unwise for them to express admiration for the eagles, or to talk to them, and while this was considered rude by community standards, it was nonetheless considered an understandable necessity on the part of the families who were as risk of suffering such a notable honor as having their young daughter chosen in the ceremony.

It was perhaps unfortunate that it was this affinity for eagles that cemented her selection. The young girl had been carefully coached in private by her parents as to how to behave, and had learned to scream at the sight of snakes, and to express disgust at the prospect of eating beetles, and to furthermore apply  oil to her skin that was meant to ask as a repellant should one venture in her vicinity. And she was permitted and, indeed, encouraged to climb up the side of the mountain, and the story was told about how the many eagles that kept nests up there were quick to flee her presence, and to screech in anger, although to tell the truth, the young girl never did venture too close, and the eagles never did fly away when they saw her approaching, but instead watched her calmly, and would eagerly consume the small bits of meat that she left for them and that she carried hidden in her pocket, as an offering she felt she was obliged to make in return for the eagles’ feathers that she loved to pick up.

And it was the discovery of the eagle’s feathers that did her in, for when she was climbing down during one of her forays to the top that observed to pull out a bundle from her pocket let them loose in the wind. The feathers were much prized by ordinary members of her community, but any affinity for them among the candidates was bound to be considered a particularly fortunate omen for the work of the conclave, who received notice of the news, at the same time as the parents of the young girl, who were quite understandably overcome with pride and happiness, to the extent that the mother cried out loudly and commences pulling out her hair, and the father beat his other children mercilessly for not keeping watch over their sister, and then ran out of their house, where he was seen picking up and throwing stones over the side of the terrace, and running back and forth in what was supposed to be interpreted as a peculiar form of exaltation, but one that left him trembling and shaken at his unexpected good fortune.

It was forthwith decided that the young girl would the chosen bride, and the announcement was made that night.

To be continued


OGRomero © 2013
(Copyrighted by OGRomero, 2013)

Monday, September 2, 2013

Summer as Quest (Labor Day 2013)




This is the time of the year when I would normally start panicking. It being late August, we find ourselves once again cresting on a rising tide of suffocating heat that traditionally engulfs the entire Southwest during the Labor Day holiday, sapping our strength and leaving us cowering inside our air-conditioned buildings. What had seemed until a few short weeks ago a mild summer has proven to be yet another deceptive promise, and sooner or later accounts were bound to be settled. The heat, after all, is an unavoidable mainstay of this region, smothering everything in its wake and signaling once again a fiery end to the summer. Of course it was silly to believe otherwise, for don’t we live in a topographical salad bowl of natural high pressure, bounded by mountains as we are and located in a southern latitude? I speak of the weather as if it were the cause of the anxiety mentioned in the opening, but as usual it is necessary to search below the surface to come to an understand of a period of the year that I have now come to associate with latent and nervous expectancy.

By now, school has been in session for several weeks, earlier than ever. This early start is a recent change, and it wasn’t always so. I remember that the reprieve for public school students lasted until after the Labor Day holiday, but nowadays, school calendars have been adjusted, one suspects, in order to accommodate budgetary concerns, although claims are made that earlier starts are necessary to extend the school year and offset other breaks that are now allotted. It is early August and we now see the uncharacteristic sight of school buses disgorging crowds of students, and long lines of cars around our many public schools during periods of drop-off and pick-up. I see the students from my old high school slouching slowly down the streets in the early afternoon, heading towards Bethlehem and waiting to be born, if I may paraphrase the famous poem by Yeats. I wonder about the cycles of life, and can’t help but reflect on my own journey.

The start of the school year must come like a shock to everyone involved. It is certainly the case for the teachers, faced with the prospect once again of new groups of students who must seem as unruly and untamed as ever, irritated all the more so by the fact that the hot weather outside leaves them feeling cheated, bound as they are to their desks. The old adage proclaims that school is a waste of good health, and I suppose young people must feel it much more than older people do.

I remember the pain of having to return to school, and in particular, the transition between junior high and high school. It was hotter than we could bear outside, and I was more nervous than I could confess when I received my appointment to register for the academic term. I remember my first impressions, seeing young men who sported beards and openly smoked in designated areas, and young women who liked just as glamorous as the icons we saw on television, in shows such as Charley’s Angels. They were much more confident that I could ever imagine being, and when they weren’t mocking us freshmen and sophomores, they took no notice of us. We were beneath contempt, in other words, and I felt that many of my teachers treated me the same way.

As if the start of each academic term wasn’t nerve-wracking enough, we had to deal with the intense heat, made worse by frequently airless classrooms. We were soaked in sweat, sitting next to the attractive girls who we imagined had the olfactory sense of bloodhounds, and were bound to denounce us for the foibles of biology and the weather. It didn’t help that some of our teacher found it necessary to snap at us as well as we fell under the soporific influence of the heat.  These conditions made everyone irritable, something that was evident inside and outside of school, as much in the past as in the present as well.

For one thing, drivers were more irritable, and I remember the glares if I dawdled too long at a light, or drove too slowly.  My first car accident took place during an August long ago, after I had graduated from UCLA and begun my career as an engineer. I was having difficulty adjusting, and was reporting to a lab facility where I felt I was being hazed in subtle as well as obvious ways, making the prospect of reporting to work very unpleasant. I made a left turn into the path of an oncoming car that I was sure should have started stopping because the light had turned orange, but instead accelerated and barreled straight into the side of my car. I did a half spin, and I remember the feeling of disorientation and shock that seemed to encapsulate when I associated with this conjunction of August, the heat, and a job that wasn’t for me. Blame it on the season and on eternal human foibles.

There is no telling if the heat, in the same way that alcohol does, doesn’t peel away inhibitions. Besides all the instances of irritability I perceived in others, and which I would also have to acknowledge myself, I couldn’t help but think of it as the missing element, the catalyst that brought existing unstable chemical (read personal as well as social) conflicts to a boil. It was during one summer long ago that still shimmers in my memory that we heard a knock on our front door late at night, after we had all gone to bed. It turned out to be our neighbor, a middle-aged woman who looked like an apparition out of a ghost story, with a swollen face, a black eye and blood that was trickling down from the corner of her mouth. She was crying softly, and we kids forgot our manners as our parents spoke to this neighbor, the mother of our friends, and asked them for their help driving her to her parents’ home. I remember the same feeling of disorientation, a dreamlike quality that accompanies seeing something that your mind is not quite prepared to accept, rationalize it as we may, and all the while, our neighbor’s husband was yelling drunkenly from his front yard, threatening my parents if they intervened in what he said was a private matter.

My car crash was one such episode, and this memory of seeing a battered woman pleading for help was another that helped to cement the thought I had that summer was when misfortune and a pulling back of the veils was most apt to occur. It was as if the sunlight was a merciless goad that accentuated existing conflicts, the feeling of not fitting in, the fears that we all had, in the same way that we shed perspiration.  Was this not once again the effect of the heat, of those long stretches of unbearable days in which our misfortunes seem more unbearable than ever before, when the underlying dynamics of an unstable situation were revealed? And could we not extend this as well to other scales, to the social element and to that we associated with social movement, to the epoch that seems so long ago but that in reality was of recent vintage, the era of the Civil Rights movement?

There were, of course, idyllic moments as well. As stressful as it might have been for our parents to have us alone in our house while they were forced to attend to their jobs, or as stressful as it was to make the adjustment to a new school, there were still quiet moments of contemplation when I could reflect on my past. For one thing, the heat makes us lethargic, and the long breaks (for those of us who were lucky not to have to work) left us with long afternoons when time seemed endless and we eagerly awaited the cool breezes of the afternoon. Maybe we might be lucky enough to see vast storm clouds in the sky, which might or might not offer a moment of relief. We could play with the radio on our parents’ stereo set, and listen to the stations that were forbidden to hear otherwise, those that played top ten hits in English, and that our parents would never let us listen to otherwise because they were afraid we were acculturating too quickly. There were the adventures with friends while riding on our bikes, when I hesitate to admit that, yes, I would leave my younger sister and brother alone at home watching television while I would take a quick ride up the street to see who could better imitate Evel Knevel, me or my friend. And there were the long hours watching reruns on television, the game shows that we barely understood, the ribald remarks, the spectacle of untrammeled consumerism and materialist glee, the episodes of the Three Stooges or Gilligan’s Island or, of course, my favorite, the episodes of Star Trek, where I could project my own desires.

Miraculously I managed to avoid being struck by drivers when I rode my bike recklessly, drivers who nonetheless cursed me liberally and creatively, throwing in a few offensive ethnic remarks, and giving me the perverse pleasure of thinking that they deserved it.  And there were the hours spent at the library, browsing in the science fiction section and trying to be strategic about how I would tackle the task of reading the entire collection maintained by the library. Start with the serializations of Star Trek, especially those published by the noted British science fiction writer James Blish, then proceed to the Hugo and Nebula award winners, then to those that had rave reviews on their covers by other authors I admired, then to those that had interesting covers, then to those that mentioned the presence of space ships in their blurbs, etc.

The library was always a special haunt for me, and I found it easy to imagine that I was indeed on a space ship, for the library had big windows and, on particularly hot days, there were few pedestrians outside, contributing to the illusion that we were traveling through an empty landscape, maybe on one of those multi-generational ships that would take thousands of years to reach the nearest star, and maybe, just maybe, my generation was the one that would live to see the promise fulfilled of arrival. More than a few times I must have been caught napping, to the annoyance of the librarians, but how could I explain that it was just an instance of cryogenic suspension?

The intensity of the heat would build slowly during the summer. As the days grew longer, the long stretches of time dizzied us. We needed a break from all that time, a way to make it less onerous, and perhaps it is this impulse that makes us reserve our summers for ambitious projects, for trips, for home improvement projects, for picking up a new skill, for practicing an old one, and just for trying to find a way to lighten the load. Older teenagers live for the nightlife, what exists in such a backwards corner of California as Corona was, an outlying suburb of Los Angeles where people could make their salaries stretch a little more, even if we were more prone to fires. I remember that as we hit August the heat would crest, and we would be bombarded then as now by the same breathless reports on the news about heat waves, about crowded freeways, and about gang shootings in Los Angeles.

Living in Los Angeles at the time, little did we know about the underlying conflicts that were slowly coming to a boil. I remember the report of the slaying of an African-American teenager, Latasha Harkins by a Korean market owner, way back in March of 1991, an event that took place shortly after the beating of motorist Rodney King, and which presaged an explosion that was sure to come. There had always been long-simmering tensions not only in East Los Angeles but also in south central districts, and the stories of drive-by shootings dramatically punctuated our newscasts. Things were not going well in our city, and yet we continued going through the motions, with most of the residents in the West Los Angeles area where I lived shaking their heads sadly when I broached the topic. The celebratory glow of Los Angeles in the wake of the 1984 Olympics was slowly being snuffed out, and there was a sense of unease, of that nervous expectancy that I spoke of and that I associated with the summers. Hadn’t the Watts riots taking place during the summer, during a fateful weak in August of 1965?

There was a special edge to the reporting of crimes during the summer months, and a feeling of menace that accrued to statistics that showed an increase in crimes. Gangs were much in the news, and it was perhaps inevitable that there would be a sensationalistic response on the part of Hollywood. We had witnessed the release of the movie “Colors”, movies that tied in with the popular theme of social breakdown, in this case, attributed not to overpopulation or to ecological despoliation, but to certain social phenomena that were associated with ethnic communities, a sort of threat to the “Western” values that was so breathlessly denounced by conservative figures in their critique of academe and the “liberal” press. It was all coming to a boil, the inevitable reaction.

Well, the Rodney King riots arrived with an inevitable fatality in April 1992. I remember the evening when the results of the first trial acquitting the officers were read, for I was at UCLA, attending an evening poetry class that was offered through their evening extension program. We heard reports about window being broken in Westwood, and we briefly considered whether or now we should cancel the class before we decided to continue.  Although they took place in April, and they gave rise to several long and dreary days of rioting, with the smell of despair and anger in the afternoon reaching us all the way in west Los Angeles, these memories have a summer edge to them in my mind. They were tied, once again, to the conception I had that sunlight was capable as much of deceiving us as of releasing our innermost fears (and hopes), and the light of those Korean storefronts were like the fires that blazed through the deserts, canyons and hills during the summer, a fire that was meant to cleanse, even if it left us with the sordid aftertaste of footage we will never forget, such as the beating of the white truck driver, Reginald Denny.

There had always been fires during the summer, reported breathlessly on local news coverage. There occurred in outlying areas, in canyons, in the mountains around Santa Monica, in Angeles National Forest, and even in what I imagined were the few remaining wild places in Orange County. Was it possible to assign these events a social dimension as well? We were certainly captivated by the footage that was transmitted to us by the news choppers, and sometimes, when traveling to visit family members in Riverside County, I might happen to see the smoke plumes that transmitted what seemed to me to be messages waiting to be deciphered. Once, the fires reached the southern hills on the outskirts of Corona, and they blazed live lava flows, with residents being urged to stay inside and avoid breathing the air. As if it were that easy to separate ourselves, in the same way that the flames in South Central Los Angeles engulfed the whole psychic imaginary of the nation in 1992.

If ghosts can be interpreted as symbolic representations of unresolved conflicts, then the fires that we say in a way served a parallel function, for just as they indicated a social breakdown in Los Angeles during the Watts and the Rodney King riots, they indicated a pattern of unsustainable an unrealistic land development that pointed to social divisions that were widening in California. New settlements are built on outlying areas that are meant to be protected by a cushion of separation from our urban areas, for these settlements are typically reserved for higher income households, and they are evidence of how urban flight is impinging on our few remaining wildlife areas, where brush and trees prove just as combustible as the tortured and conflictive social dynamics in other areas. Many of these fires are set by arsonists, we must add, and while no social agenda is proclaimed, one can’t help but think they are motivated by instances of socially marginalized individuals who are expressing a message of rebellion, even if they don’t recognize it as such. And in the meantime, Nero continues to fiddle while Rome burns.

The nervous expectancy of summers was also evoked by moments of transition. I remember, for example, my first teaching post in Kansas. I arrived in mid-August, flying into Kansas City during my birthday and thinking that it couldn’t possibly be as hot as Riverside County which I had just left behind. I was chagrined to find out that the heat was probably more intense and uncomfortable than any I had experience before, and I kept on thinking of the Portuguese word, “abafado”, that always had sounded to me like a stew. The difference, of course, was attributable to the qualitative difference in the heat, specifically, to the humidity, but it might also have had to do with the anxiety I felt.

It was unnerving to fly into a new region so far away (I am speaking of cultural distance, principally) with only two suitcases and the crushing pressure of having to deal with what in all likelihood would be skepticism. For one thing, it felt as if I were submerged underwater, unable to dry out as I quickly drenched my clothing by simply waiting outside for the shuttle bus to the rental car agency. But my first impression of the skies in the Midwest was that they were, quite simply, amazing, and I felt as times as if it was only the weight of that sweat that soaked my clothing that prevented me from flying up and losing myself in their azure clarity. I still treasure the sight of those wide open landscapes, even as I looked around and found myself isolated, missing as I did the omnipresence of Latinos such as myself that I take for granted in California. The prairies were wide open, and I left Missouri to drive west into the Sunflower state.

The blue of the sky seemed to me to be more intense than any I had seen before, with vast and lonely clouds that loomed up majestically, these floating balloons of water that served as projections for my soul. The sky was clearer out here, with none of the haze that we associate with southern California, and it was hypnotic to look up and to see these clouds coalesce into a landscape in the sky, an aerial topography that left me with visions of Greek islands, and with heroes sailing out among them, in pursuit of their own individual quests. I couldn’t help but compare myself with Odysseus, though less hardy, for the heat was thoroughly oppressive as I settled myself for the lonely drive on the two lane highway (one of the narrowest highways I had ever experienced), following Apollo as he drove his chariot into the west.

I arrived in that city in the early evening and immediately noticed the buzz of the cicadas. I didn’t know quite how to characterize it in the beginning, and I am ashamed to admit it now, but thought for some time that it might have been noise produced by the power grid. It would throb over and over, even as it got darker and darker, and it was louder where we found trees. The noise was insistent and reminded me of a B-grade science fiction movie so popular in the 50s, with scientists in medieval castles and arcs of electricity jumping from one node to the next, to be wielded no doubt to give life to another Frankenstein. Of course I quickly realized that it was due to the cicadas, but still, it felt a little eerie, with that feeling that we were in late summer and something was bound to happen. Some cataclysm, perhaps, but also, maybe, some spectacle of wonder. Truth be told, my imagination had already been molded by the science fiction novels and movies I had always enjoyed, and it was quite natural to think of Ursula K. Le Guin novels, of Star Trek episodes, and of Ray Bradbury’s poetic homage to summers, Dandelion Wine.

It is a truism that summers have a certain idyllic quality to them, despite the nervous energy and the air of expectancy that I have described. If we associate winter with decline and conclusion, summers suggest plenitude, the bright moment when action can and should be taken, when we are at the peak of our creative powers, facing with the tantalizing prospect of actualizing possibilities. It is nonetheless a moment, and it does draws inexorably towards its own conclusion, in that final frenetic holiday that is signaled by Labor Day, a holiday that in the United States is putatively associated with a tribute to the working individual, but is denuded of any real political essence and is thoroughly unlike the May Day celebrations held throughout the rest of the world. Labor Day is the last fling of the summer before we settle down and behave like adults, as our parents admonished it was necessary to do.

By the end of August, then, the lazy succession of bright and hot days filled with barbeques and summer projects that we have been undertaking, with books we have been reading and lawns and vegetable gardens we have been cultivating (my summer tomatoes turned out nicely, I might add), and with articles and reviews we have proposed to complete because this is the time that is set aside for academics to pursue their investigations without the interruptions represented by department service, all come to a frenetic conclusion as we come to the realization that, yes, this period is drawing to a close, and the tyranny of the clock will resume. Can we rebel against the end of the summer?

I contemplate once again the need to buy clothes, and the prospect of setting aside the T-shirts and shorts I had been wearing up to this point and striking instead a different sartorial note. This can’t help but remind me of the last futile (but in my mind desperately ennobling) gesture of one of my English professors at UCLA, Lynn Batten, who was a bit of a ham and who arrived at the first lecture of the fall term about twenty years ago looking decidedly unprofessorial in his Bermuda shorts, T-shirt and sneakers, challenging us as he stood in front of the class. “What?!” he exclaimed, “Is the summer over yet? I say NO!”, and we all laughed, we students settling into another evening extension course, and in my case, an engineer who had left behind his job and was planning a career change to pursue the literature degree I had always wanted. His need to proclaim his faith in an eternal summer mirrored my own to justify what I was doing, and to pursue once again another transition, to pick up the elements of a past that I hadn’t been able to fashion correctly, and to proclaim a faith in infinite possibilities. I was a rebel too.

So we gear up for the final swan song for the summer 2013, recognizing as well the symbolic import of this period, and the historical moments we associate with August. Summers have been associated with many personal moments of transition in my life, and there is also the added social dimension that is present in the celebration of the 50th anniversary (today, August. 30th), of the speech given by the Reverend Martin Luther King at the Washington Memorial Monument back in 1963. Summer back then had the promise of change, the way it did decades later in Los Angeles during the riots, the way it did on a more personal note when I landed in Kansas City. We sing to the idyllic nature of a season that is grounded in dreams, in vast cloudscapes in the sky, but also in dark moments, in the anger and tension that broods underneath, in the fires that blaze because we need to believe that we can change things, even if it is more difficult that we can imagine to change an institutional framework, an economic system or a cultural outlook (they are all connected, of course). We sing the praises of those idyllic moments, the wafting barbeque smells, the sound of children laughing by the pool, the Mexican immigrant paletero who pushes his cart through the barrios selling Mexican icicle pops, and yes, the cicadas buzzing insistently as the raccoons sort through our trash. And yes, maybe somewhere in the streets of major cities where hope is more muted, in the urban wastelands of Chicago or Oakland or South Central Los Angeles, a bullet also zings its way with a crack in an arc of futility.

We are formed by our social institutions, and by the calendars that define our rituals and routines. We are creatures of habit, after all. But is it also true that we respond to nature, and that this need not be considered an imposition but, instead, an acknowledgement of the cycle of youth, maturity and what I will call senescence, for it is an elegant euphemism. I tell myself that as a society, we still have a ways to go, and that urgency is building once again, especially given the climate of futility that prevails in Washington.  As we prepare to enter the Labor Day weekend, and as our president maneuvers to involve as in yet another Middle East conflict, and as immigration reform stalls in the House of Representatives where any legislation with the slightest progressive edge is sent to die, and when we settle down in a tepid economic recovery that will most likely stall once again due to the machinations of extremists political movements, I can still lose myself to the idyllic pleasure of looking up at the skies during a hot August afternoon, contemplating the beautiful  vista of storm clouds during this time of the year. Summer is, after all, a part of the eternal pageant of giving oneself over to the mythical quest of discovery. Like driving west on Highway 70 in the middle of the vast prairie once again.  



OGRomero © 2013
(Copyrighted by OGRomero, 2013)

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

Gargantuan Foibles (A Review of "Pacific Rim")


 
The summer blockbuster is a Hollywood institution that has proven to be highly profitable. It taps into certain formulas that are perceived to appeal deeply to audiences that will return again and again to see the same film. This audience, by and large, consists of a younger demographic, and these films tend to combine a mixture of action with the charisma of proven Hollywood stars. The relationships are portrayed broadly, and seem to revolve around the following elements: young couples from different circumstances or with different temperaments, friends who bond in a given social setting (the “buddy” pics), and the perennial portrayal of “in” and “out” groups in conflict. There is also a heavy dose of special effects in movies that tend to be premised on fantasy premises as well as science fiction scenarios that revolve, over and over, around the fear of invasion and conquest. (How realistic can these scenarios be, as the astronomer Seth Shostak has noted, if we take into account that an alien civilization able to cross interstellar space would of necessity possess a vastly-superior technology that would render moot the possibility of resistance?). In these blockbusters there is also, of course, an element of escapism, rivalry between peers who compete for the affection of the woman, almost always a woman in these male-centered epics, and scenarios of military conflict that correspond to geopolitical concerns, or to phenomena such as terrorism. These films are not particularly subtle, and instead tend to be loud, punctuated as they are by repeated explosion or chase sequences that build to a thrilling climax that, unfortunately, always tends to revolve around countdowns and a spectacular explosion. There is little in the way of intellectual stimulation and, indeed, this would interfere with the adrenaline rush these blockbusters are meant to provide. These films, borrowing as I wish to do and appealing to the full metaphorical sense of the title, are “No country for Old Men”, and no material for those who have a modicum of education.

I was thinking about these components as I was watching Guillermo Del Toro’s latest film, the blockbuster titled Pacific Rim. After the first few minutes, I knew that this film was not meant for me, but decided to stay to watch it until the end, against my better judgment. Del Toro is known for having directed several films that we may categorize as belonging to the genre of fantasy and horror, starting with his memorable Cronus. He has also incorporated lyrical themes that have to do with the nature of repression, and the political subtext in films such as Pan’s Labyrinth and El espinazo del diablo (The Devil’s Backbone) is very much in evidence. He has also tapped into popular culture, having brought to the screen Mike Mignolo’s comic book character, “Hellboy”, yet another fable about an outsider who renounces his fate and circumstances to chart an alternate course, what we would tend to view as turning his back on his “natural” affiliation, only to uphold the dominant (bourgeois) ethos of the social group that we can all identify with, which is, that of western consumer culture. These, as well as the stylish Blade films, may be termed action films, but they aren’t one-dimensional. They are characterized at times by humor and wit, and at other times by an investigation of the moral compass that guides individuals as they struggle to question the imperatives of the societies that bind and encircle them. They have tended to be masterful in their handling of tone, conveying at times nostalgia, at times menace, and at times wonder as well as incorporating a lyrical note. For the most part I’ve enjoyed Del Toro’s films, despite the fact that they are highly commercial.

In his latest film, we have an homage to the monster movies that were a mainstay of Japanese movie studios such as Toho films in the 50s through 70s. These films featured an array of gigantic creatures, monsters ranging from Godzilla to Gamera, Rodan to King Ghidorah, that were a mainstay of my youth. These were giant monsters that were as tall as skyscrapers, and while the earliest Godzilla movie featured an extended sequence in which the monster tore through Tokyo on a path to destruction that encapsulated what appeared to be a punitive mission against humanity, a punishment as if were for the sins of humanity in the wake of the atomic age. It was a deeply mesmerizing film, and it inaugurated a whole genre that morphed into a wholly different entity, films that highlighted not only the upsetting of a natural balance (we have a “Smog” monster that appears in a later film) but also movies that can’t be categorized as anything other than thinly-disguised westerns, with humanity standing by passively on the sides as they watched these monsters engage in combat. There was interaction with humans as well, typically with children, as the Japanese directors mined the deep fascination that children have always had with their elders, who can at times assume frightening aspects akin to those of monsters. Children also have an enduring fascination with these figures as well, as noted in the enduring appeal of books such as Maurice Sendak’s Where the Wild Things Are, or the Pixar Monsters, Inc. movies (or the wolves of old in ancient fairy tales).

The monsters in the Japanese films of this period all had their own personalities, and it was easy to identify and in some way project our hopes and fears on them. Godzilla, in particular, was domesticated as the films progressed, and he came to seem like the embodiment, in oversized dinosaur garb, of a curmudgeonly father, perpetually ill-tempered and foul-breathed but also willing to enter the fray and defend humanity, defend his son and defend the society of monsters. Gamera, the flying turtle, was like an older brother, somehow more cerebral in my conception, always willing to hear the entreaties of children and able to withdraw into his shell and fly away, shooting flames while rotating. He always did seem particularly protective of young children and, when it comes down to it, as I suggested before, we could say that the monster movies were westerns transposed into the modern age and urban setting, with gunslingers (or more accurately, fire-breathers) who came from far away (the depths of the sea, outer space, “Monster Island”) in order to uphold community values in the face of disruption by outsiders. The spectacle of seeing these monsters, in sets that were designed to accentuate this sense of scale, were always immensely appealing to me, even if I always wondered why it was that beings made of organic materials felt nothing when stepping on a tank and crushing it, while I always howled in pain if I made the mistake of stepping on a hot wheel with my bare foot.

In Guillermo Del Toro’s latest film, the premise is that, once again, outsiders come to threaten the community with destruction. In this case, these are gigantic lizard-like monsters who come to be known as “kaijus”, and they emerge from a trench under the sea, one that constitutes a portal between dimensions. These monsters start out as blundering entities, attacking cities located throughout the Pacific rim, but after being repelled, they come to slowly evolve, so that they are assigned different categories. Humanity is under threat, then, and in this latest instance of the Western genre, we have need of a group of defenders, the Seven Samurai, so to speak, who, as in Akira Kurosawa’s classic film, will band together and overcome their differences in order to defeat this menace. These are the mechas, the Jaegers (hunters) who are operated by teams of two people who have a type of neural interface that allows them to operate these mammoth beings. Why these operators have to be located within the gargantuan metallic object and can’t operate it the way modern armies operate drones escapes me.

What we have, unfortunately, is a case of blockbusteritis. I came in knowing that the premise was fairly formulaic, having been done many times before, and that furthermore this film was meant in some way to hark back on the Japanese films we had seen before, thirty or forty years ago. But somehow it didn’t translate very well, something that has been evident as well in other recent remakes of classic monster films that have been updated (read, spoiled by special effect and one-dimensional plots). Perhaps it has to do with tone, and with the idea that there was always an emotional heart to the old films that is not present in these bloated summer blockbusters of recent times. Perhaps it is more difficult to care about yet one more scenario involving the destruction of humanity, when we have become so jaded about the state of our modern world, and when, as mentioned in this movie as a type of ecological warning about the dangers of global warming, we have brought this once again upon ourselves. At least in the monster movies that I remember from the past, there was much less ideological ambiguity when we considered the children who viewed these monsters from afar, and we could view them as innocent fables, as westerns, so to speak. In this case, this emotional heart is lacking, and no abundance of repetitive action sequences that feature mechas (or, more appropriately, the term should be cyborgs, for these are humans interfaced with gargantuan mechanical weapons platforms that take human form) can compensate, not even when you throw the pro forma personnel conflicts that involve the sacrifice of brothers, sons and mentors.

Very quickly the actions sequences grew stale. The premise was one that was difficult to credit, but when you are playing it as realism, and not as fable, it came to seem all the more like a cynical ploy to achieve commercial success and to generate market demand for the associated products, for the toys (one of the scientists in the movie has what seems to be a fetish revolving around kaiju of different categories, to which he has assigned names and categorized, as if he were in charge of future marketing), videogames and assorted by-products that were sure to accompany this film. The giant cyborg defenders are once again crewed by outsiders who are iconoclasts and non-comformists, who don’t otherwise fit into modern society, but who are redeemed by their talents. They can’t obey orders, because they have their own code of honesty, their own moral imperatives. We have, once again, a group of pilots, and the personnel who are in charge of supporting them, and we have the short-sighted bureaucrats, the effete leaders, the politicians who lack vision and are unable to give the necessary level of support or guidance. The pilots, in effect, are fighting against each other (there are rivalries), fighting against themselves (with unresolved family conflicts that torment their psyches), fighting with their managers, and finally, fighting against the external threat posed by the kaiju. Could the odds be more stacked against them?

There was a very notable cartoonish quality to these combat sequences that grew repetitive very quickly. This is due, in large part, to the emphasis on action sequences that is one of the guiding elements of all summer blockbusters, combined as it was with computer-generated spectacle. After five minutes I grew frustrated with the wrestling and martial arts moves of these behemoth characters, as if immense creatures could swerve and pivot on a dime, weighing as they did thousands of tons, and felt that there was no grounding for a psychological understanding of the outsider. Yes, it turns out, they (the kaijus) are soldiers as well, sent to “clean” out the human species so that they can colonize the planet, but these monsters seem strangely anonymous, despite their ferocious appearance. They spew acid, they have curling tails that whip at their rivals (the jaegers/cyborgs), and they are capable of playing dead, but frustratingly, they have no personality. Perhaps one may argue that they are an alien species and that they can’t be anthropomorphized, but if their mission is one that is fully comprehensible in human terms (that of conquest and colonization), then we have already defined them in familiar terms. What we have, instead, is a series of monsters who arrive and are sequentially defeated, with the last one, the category 5 monster encountered at the trench, being supposedly the most terrifying one.

What is comes down to is this: is this a political fable or a simple wrestling match? Is this an allegory about the threat of invasion and takeover, a la “Invasion of the Body Snatchers”, or a homily about family values and the need to reconcile, or a projection of fears that western industrialized societies have with regards to immigration from their southern neighbors, transposed, now, to another dimension (the trench as the tunnel that serves as the passageway for subversives)? It is hard to make it out as such, when what we see is another formulaic exercise that revels in bloated special effects and simplistic interpersonal dynamics. It is hard to believe or see any passion in this film, and it all seems forced, like the farewell between father and son who are unable to continue as a team, or the limp romance between the protagonist (Raleigh Becket) and his Japanese female co-pilot (Mako Mori), the one who will supposedly reclaim him after the tragedy in which he suffered the loss of his brother.

I suppose you have to be a certain age to enjoy summer blockbusters. At times, these films can tap into hidden reservoirs of wonder, and when combined with engaging human relationships, they can leave a lasting imprint. Such was the case for so many of my generation, when we first saw “Star Wars” back in the late 70s. It is not the case with this latest film by Guillermo Del Toro that seems to turn its back on the playful, and at times gleeful, but also admonitory note that he frequently incorporated in his films. In the end, the movie, like the monsters that inhabit it, proved to be a highly bloated special effects creation that was all ferocious and glitzy exterior, but quite empty inside.

Give me the rubber suits but, also, the innocence of the old Japanese monster movies any time.

 
OGRomero © 2013
(Copyrighted by OGRomero, 2013)

Wednesday, August 21, 2013

The Magical Island (Review of Laputa: Castle in the Sky)


 
 
Hayao Miyazaki is an acknowledged master of anime, a genre of filmmaking that combines animation with themes from Japanese culture. I understand and appreciate that animation as a genre is popular throughout the world, and that other countries have cultivated it as well, with notable recent examples being the French film The Triplets of Belleville. Furthermore, different national traditions in animation are enhanced by association with related media platforms, of which we may signal out the publication of illustrated books (comics) known as bandes dessinées for Francophone audiences and, of course, the vigorous manga tradition in Japan. In these cultural expressions there are elements of melodrama and fantasy, as well as themes and images derived from the cultural and symbolic language of science fiction, crime serializations (notable in creations such as Fantomas) and comic historical epics (think Asterix in Belgium or Lone Wolf and Cub in Japan). They are all melded with a vigorous youth culture that thrives on fan clubs, the collection of associated consumer products such as clothing, action figures and others, conventions, role-playing (of which we can single out, for example, cosplay) and other mediums of participation. However, anime as developed in Japan seems to have developed its own distinct national characteristics, a style and outlook as well as a catalogue of narrative formulas that distinguish it from the animation that is practiced in other countries.

In the case of Miyazaki, his films seem to revolve around stories that we may describe as modern-day folk tales with a pastoral note. There is a timeless quality to so many of them, even if they may be situated in epochs that may range from the pre-industrial age (Princess Mononoke) to industrial (Howl’s Moving Castle) to the modern post-industrial era where consumerism is erasing national mythologies and, by extension, unique spiritual values (Spirited Away, winner of the Best Animated Feature Academy Award in 2002). It is striking to me how often these stories involve characters, almost always young girls, who face difficult circumstances and who learn moral lessons that involve learning to trust one’s instincts (reinforcing unique spiritual values associated with a particular culture), find a firmer connection with society while at the same time maintaining a sense of wonder and innocence, as a reaction to the convergence of predatory forces so often unleashed in these films.

In Laputa: Castle in the Sky, released in 1986, we have one of the first films to have been written and directed by Hayao Miyazaki, and produced by Studio Ghibli. It amply illustrates several of the themes listed above, all combined with the strong storytelling that has been a feature of all of his films. It is on one level a caper film with two young protagonist (the orphans Sheeta and Pazu, the first being a mysterious girl who drops out of the sky in the opening sequence and the latter being a young and industrious boy who lives in a mining town) who are chased by pirates as well as government agents. We also have elements of fantasy that reveal a deep-seated psychological underpinning, for example, the need that we can project for all young people to find a home of their own, and to make sense of their past, both personal as well as social, elements that are involved in any rite of passage. And, we have a tale of wonder with implied political commentary, evident in the quest for a magical place, the castle in the sky, that proves a backdrop for a Faustian quest for knowledge.

 
We have seen these themes before, of course, for they have appeared over and over in epic fantasies, in fairy tales, and in political thrillers. It is the way in which these themes are seamlessly melded together that characterizes the quiet assurance of Miyazaki as a writer and animator. He manages to combine these elements to produce a film that is at once a story of innocent first love as well as a fable that warns against the dangers of Science (with a capital “S”) pursued without ethical restraint (harking back to the theme of Faust, and the allegory of power that corrupts). One obtains, from time to time, the impression that these films of Miyazaki are pastorals, by which I am referring to the idealization of a pre-industrial past, and the notion that communities and ideals back in an earlier period were much more rooted in local and sustainable traditions. There is almost always an associated element of wonder that accompanies these reflections, situated as they are not only in idealized historical epochs, but also in idealized psychosocial stages in an individual’s development, for they are evocations of the innocence of childhood. There is an element of reverie in these films, and as in all such experiences, there are moments of encounter where the sense of wonder is evoked in touching ways, depending on the scale of the encounters. We have, for example, the monumental, which is evident in view afforded by majestic cloudscapes and the quiet and peaceful gardens of Laputa, or in the almost cathedral-like forest canopy in a film such as Princess Mononoke, or more recently, in the sheer profusion of sea life that is revealed in a symphony of movement and color in the opening sequence of Ponyo. But there is also a smaller scale, that of personal contact, that is evident in small gestures, in moments of intimacy, in the way children can reach out to hold each other’s hands, or smile at the antics of a friend, as happens with the character of Turnip-head who follows around the protagonist in the movie Howl’s Moving Castle.

I am struck as well by the vertical landscapes in a film such as Laputa: Castle in the Sky. In this case it seems to play a prominent part, alluding as it does to social and well as emotional distance, and emblematized by repeated cliffhanger sequences that characterize this film. Sheeta isn’t the only protagonist who inhabits the sky, we have air-borne pirates as well, led by the middle-aged woman with pink ponytails named Dola, but also, evident in the monstrous government battleships that sweep across in great aerial vistas. And, we have a mining village that seems to be perched on a cliff like a modern-day Machu Pichu, with houses situated precariously on the very edge of precipitous cliffs, and railroad tracks that, for all the use of iron and metal in other constructions, are built, astoundingly, of wood, arcing over deep chasms. And, of course, deep down inside the mines, we have an interior landscape notable for great airy spaces, the equivalent of the sky but hallowed out in stone and reverential echoes, where the old grandfather who knows much of the lore of these communities is located, hiking alone. The stone cavern is illuminated by the shimmer of glowing reflections, provided as they are by traces of an element that is mysterious and full of power, as all such elements should be if they are to preserve an element of magic.  In the modern day equivalent, we can help but think of them as quite possible uranium or some such radioactive element, which is also lethal if concentrated or if exposure is not limited, which only serves to underscore that these disguised elements are part of a narrative that, once again, warns against scientific hubris, an enduring theme of science fiction.

 
 After having mentioned science fiction, it would seem natural as well to talk about the nature of technology in evidence in this film. It is a curious mixture that I would venture to call a form of “retro futurism”, for it harks back to what I would like to imagine is a 19th century conception of technological development. We have no circuit boards, no solid state physics, and no consumer electronics of the kind that have produced modern-day wonders such as IPhones. We have instead dirigibles made of iron that somehow are maintained in the air with immense rotors, and elaborate as well as massive pipe works that provide the power necessary to excavate the earth, and of course, steam trains that run on charcoal and that seem strangely quaint as they chug along wooden tracks that disintegrate during chase sequences. How will the destruction of these tracks and bridges impact a mining community that depends on this mode of transportation to deliver the products they extract from the mines, when it is evident that reconstructing them will be subject to immense delays? There is, notably, little social realism in these films, and no true representation of the poor and their suffering, where pain is more emotional rather than economic, but we are talking, once again, about pastorals, and the idealization of distant realms.

The flying vehicles that are flown by the family of pirates resemble nothing so much as iron gnats or ladybugs, and the daredevil moves of the pilots as they fly through the sky produce an adrenaline rush that is evoked continually in this film. Vertical thrill are much in evidence in this film, one in which protagonists are always on the verge of falling off cliffs, sky ships, bridges, railroad tracks or a floating island, but one in which these predicaments are conveyed with an element of whimsy rather than nail-biting terror. In one sequence towards the end of the film, the young boy Pazu is forced to cling desperately to the roots of the giant tree that are revealed as the lower levels of the island begin to crumble away, in another cliffhanger sequence that can’t help but recall the famous scene in the film The Empire Strikes Back when Luke Skywalker is similarly perched beneath the fortress of Lando Calrissian. It is, then, what I could venture to say a Victorian vision of the future in which domestic arrangements and prosperity is threatened by the operation of grander social institutions that have become unmoored from local communities, operating with a level of detachment without moral restraint that as a fable exerts a powerful hold on the imagination particularly now, in the 21st century.
 
And we have robots, giant and silent creatures that lumber like industrial age golems, the personal servants of the inheritors of Laputa and guardians of the realm. These robots can themselves be turned against their charges and are capable of wielding immense destructive energy, for not only are they almost indestructible, they also shoot energy beams from their eyes. They point, once again, to the message that is underscored again and again in this film, that of the perils of unrestrained (read, unethical) technological development, and to the allegorical foundation of this theme which is found in Mary Shelley’s classic novel, Frankenstein.

 
It must be remarked that a Miyazaki film would not be complete if it were not for the inclusion of themes not only of reconciliation (with society, with the land, with oneself) but also of redemption. This is part of the moral underpinning of his films, and I am struck over and over by how often it is that the innocent protagonists in his films reach out to their putative enemies and, in a sense, redeem them, providing as they do an experience that is characteristic of melodrama. After all, as the critic Peter Brooks noted so long ago, melodrama so often involves revealing what we could call the “moral occult”, the true moral qualities of the protagonists that were hidden, and in redeeming figures who had previously seemed beyond redemption (a powerful element in romantic literature as well). Which is not to say that we don’t have villains who, in their malevolence, seem frustratingly uni-dimensional and remind me of the simplistic conception of neocons and social conservatives in this country who like to speak in simplistic terms of dichotomy between “good guys” and “bad guys”, a la George W. But we also have hidden allies, which in many of Miyazaki’s films takes the form of wizened, vigorous and comic old women, characters such as Dola the “Captain” of the pirates, or in the case of a film such as Howl’s Moving Castle, the chastened “Witch of the Waste”. That is part of the joy of these films, seeing how this moral spectacle unfolds by the coherence of a new family, incorporating individuals who previously had seemed so threatening to the protagonists. This serves to underscore, once again, a moral lesson, that allies are found everywhere, even in the outsiders of society.

The film was highly enjoyable, and while it is one of Miyazaki’s earlier films, it already shares many of the themes that appear again and again in his oeuvre. The idea of the magic island, invested with magical powers and in need of a sovereign who can wield its power, whether rightly or wrongly, is one that has epic qualities and that resonates deeply in the Western imagination. It is found in Homer, in the narrative of travellers, soldiers and heroes who wish to reclaim their inheritance or to prove themselves, and it is evident in a work such as Shakespeare’s The Tempest, or most recently in the popular imagination, the deeply muddled television series “Lost”. In the end, it has an allegorical quality that warns against the powerful impulse that is harbored in all of humanity, but also conveys the seduction of magical landscapes, and the search for a sense of cohesion in a fragmented world.
 


OGRomero © 2013
(Copyrighted by OGRomero, 2013)